Halloween is truly a beautiful time. It’s my favorite time of the year, no doubt about it, and I imagine most horror fans feel the same. I make it my personal mission to develop and execute a new seasonal marathon every October. I take it very seriously. I’m talking months of preparation, figuring out which new watches to add, which seasonal perennials to keep in rotation. It’s not easy, but it is my duty. I’m more than happy to share my picks with family and friends. Even though the season has come and gone, I’m still inclined to make time for spooky season classics.

One seasonal treat that I don’t mind indulging in outside the confines of October is Patrick McHale’s Over the Garden Wall. I was late to the game, only catching the series...